Three weeks before the 2020 U.S. presidential election, the New York Post published a story alleging corruption on the part of Joe Biden. Five days later, more than 50 current and former intelligence officials signed a public letter saying the story was Russian disinformation. But for intelligence officials whose job requires them to be apolitical, was that the right call?
That’s the question former Central Intelligence Agency insider Amy McAuliffe poses to Notre Dame students during a recent class focused on analytical objectivity. After providing brief context, McAuliffe lets them talk through the situation, facilitating a lively discussion. Students raise probing questions: What can be proven? Is there a meaningful distinction between current and former intelligence officials? And is there any historical precedent for a letter like this?
“For me, having conversations like this is the goal,” McAuliffe, one of four visiting distinguished professors of the practice at Notre Dame’s Keough School of Global Affairs, explains after class. “It’s about teaching students to think critically and communicate their position succinctly. I’m not here to tell them what to think. Instead, I want to teach them how to think through and talk through these important issues in a thoughtful way that helps protect our national security.”
That’s the approach McAuliffe brings to her teaching. She is relentlessly analytical and nonpartisan, seasoned by 27 years in the CIA, where she served under Democratic and Republican administrations.
McAuliffe chaired the National Intelligence Council, directed the President’s Daily Brief and led the agency’s Middle East Analytic Unit. She oversaw experts who monitored national security challenges from China, Russia and the Middle East and worked on issues including weapons proliferation and counterterrorism. And she coordinated strategic analysis, which meant telling policymakers of both parties things they didn’t want to hear.
Learning through discussion
McAuliffe invites students to model that same approach, pushing them to synthesize information, see the big picture and articulate their argument clearly and concisely. Her seminar leans heavily into the Socratic method, encouraging participants to encounter a variety of perspectives as they sharpen their own.
“My students are first-rate and always come to class prepared, and I leverage that to strengthen our discussions,” McAuliffe says. “To me, the most important thing is not just having done the reading, but having thought about it in a careful way. So for each class, I pose strategic questions for students to answer. I really want them to think critically and communicate effectively as they work through important issues.”
Those classroom conversations are part of a broader exploration of how intelligence analysis shapes policy and global decision making. This semester, students have explored the U.S. intelligence community and its roles, from gathering human intelligence to providing objective analysis and coordinating covert action.
They have also learned the role that the intelligence community plays in foreign policy decision making and evaluated different models for how intelligence experts interact with policymakers and senior military officials. Finally, students have learned the basics of congressional oversight and considered the role of ethics in analysis and espionage. And above all, they have developed informed views on the issues the class covers by sharpening their critical thinking and writing skills.
Sharing expertise with students
Students appreciate the opportunity to learn from McAuliffe. For Henry Fipp, a first-year global affairs student who wants to understand foreign policy at a deeper level, it’s all about getting an insider’s perspective.
“Discussing case studies and first-hand source material with Professor McAuliffe is an incredibly valuable opportunity,” he says. “My classmates and I are fortunate to learn at a high level from a senior intelligence professional who has significant practical experience.”
For junior Margo Schellinger, a political science and Spanish major, it’s all about access. She’s considering a career in the intelligence community and appreciates the opportunity to talk with McAuliffe after class: “She’s so accessible during office hours and encourages us to come with questions about career discernment. I definitely take full advantage of that.”
And for students like Mary Larson, a junior American studies and political science major, it’s all about McAuliffe’s perspective, one she finds factual rather than opinion-driven.
“It’s helpful to see how she approaches problems with an unbiased perspective, and how that helped her interact with policymakers as a trusted resource,” Larson says.
Listening and bridging divides
McAuliffe is happy to share her perspective and experience. Part of it, she says, is helping students decide whether they might pursue a career in the intelligence community. Part of it is helping them hone transferable analytical and communication skills that will serve them no matter their future career. But most of all, it’s about helping them solve problems through conversations that are open to other perspectives. That’s something that McAuliffe, who describes herself as nonpolitical, says is sorely lacking in today’s hyperpolarized society.
“When I decided to retire from federal service, I knew that I wanted to teach at Notre Dame, and not just because I’m an alum and the parent of an alum,” McAuliffe says. “More than anything, I appreciate that Notre Dame focuses on bipartisanship and openness to dialogue. Nowadays, people often can’t have a frank and honest conversation without getting angry. But it’s really important to be able to do that.”
Ultimately, McAuliffe says, this approach shapes her teaching style as she prepares a new generation of leaders.
“I don’t want to push views on students,” she says. “I want to help teach them to think critically so that they can develop their own view, be comfortable talking with others who hold different views, and ultimately work alongside them as public servants who help solve pressing global issues.”